Supreme Court will hear two challenges to partisan gerrymandering – ThinkProgress


The Supreme Courtroom introduced on Friday that it’ll hear challenges to 2 aggressive partisan gerrymanders — one created by Democrats in Maryland and one other by Republicans in North Carolina.

The Maryland case is Lamone v. Benisek. The North Carolina case is Rucho v. Widespread Trigger.

This may mark the second time period in a row the place partisan gerrymandering is the marquee situation on the Courtroom’s docket. Final June, the Courtroom punted on two gerrymandering circumstances — the Maryland problem and a unique case out of Wisconsin — successfully delaying decision of this situation till after Justice Anthony Kennedy left the Courtroom.

Kennedy’s loss is prone to have devastating penalties for opponents of gerrymandering. In 2004, 4 conservative members of the Supreme Courtroom rejected a problem to Pennsylvania’s congressional maps in Vieth v. Jubelirer, with all 4 becoming a member of an opinion by Justice Antonin Scalia arguing that federal courts shouldn’t be listening to partisan gerrymandering disputes in any respect.

Kennedy supplied the fifth vote to uphold the Pennsylvania maps, however his separate concurring opinion left open the likelihood that he may strike down partisan gerrymanders in a future case. And, certainly, Kennedy initially appeared prone to rule towards such gerrymanders final time period.

However Kennedy determined to not resolve this situation, and his seat is now held by Brett Kavanaugh, a much more conservative decide who’s unlikely to vote towards partisan gerrymandering.

Though the Courtroom took two circumstances, one among which entails a Democratic gerrymander, gerrymandering presently favors Republicans nationwide as a result of the GOP carried out properly in 2010 — the final 12 months earlier than a redistricting cycle. As soon as a celebration locks in an aggressive gerrymander in a selected state, furthermore, that gerrymander is troublesome to dislodge.

After the Supreme Courtroom permitted Wisconsin’s gerrymander to stay in place final June, for instance, Democratic state meeting candidates received 54 % of the favored vote within the 2018 elections. Nonetheless, Republicans received 63 % of the state meeting seats because of the Republican gerrymander in that state.

Throughout his affirmation listening to final 12 months, Kavanaugh appeared to threaten revenge towards Democratic senators who probed credible allegations that he tried to rape future psychology professor Christine Blasey Ford when the 2 have been in highschool.

“As we all know within the political system of america within the early 2000s,” Kavanaugh informed these Democrats, “what goes round comes round.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here