New Florida water policies announced by DeSantis come with some major caveats – ThinkProgress


Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) introduced a slew of main water coverage reforms in Florida on Thursday, making good on marketing campaign guarantees to deal with mounting water crises within the coastal state, together with a deeply controversial algae drawback.

However the governor declined to acknowledge local weather change within the new insurance policies whereas doing so and environmental advocates in Florida are questioning whether or not the coverage bundle goes far sufficient in its efforts to sort out the state’s issues.

On Thursday morning, DeSantis unveiled a dramatic water plan for the state. Each blue-green algae and “pink tide” — the notorious algal blooms choking the state’s coastal seashores — had been included within the announcement following a yr of controversy over find out how to struggle the poisonous, economically devastating concern.

The Blue-Inexperienced Algae Process Power launched within the plans will particularly deal with find out how to mitigate and handle that type of algae, whereas the Division of Environmental Safety (DEP) has been tasked with creating an Workplace of Resilience and Coastal Safety to deal with coastal algae and different associated issues.

Additionally included within the plan is $2.5 billion in funding dedicated to addressing restoration within the Everglades, together with safety of the state’s water sources. An Workplace of Environmental Accountability and Transparency will even be created with the intention to higher combine scientific analysis and evaluation into the DEP’s environmental insurance policies. The division will furthermore have a Chief Science Officer “coordinate and prioritize scientific knowledge.” The South Florida Water Administration District, in the meantime, is tasked with shortly transferring ahead on an Everglades reservoir venture.

“The safety of water sources is without doubt one of the most urgent points dealing with our state,” mentioned DeSantis. “That’s why right this moment I’m taking speedy motion to fight the threats which have devastated our native economies and threatened the well being of our communities.”

The information marks a significant shift in Florida, the place officers have traditionally gone as far as to ban using the phrases “local weather change” and “world warming” in official paperwork and communications. Local weather and environmental points have historically been a back-burner concern within the Sunshine State, leaving advocates excited by this week’s flip of occasions. However questions nonetheless linger concerning the viability of the insurance policies, to say nothing of how far they really go.

A welcome shift

The morning announcement took some environmental advocates unexpectedly and a number of other informed ThinkProgress they had been nonetheless assessing what the brand new insurance policies may imply for the state. Nonetheless, some state advocates engaged on local weather points indicated that they had been heartened by the information, which marks a departure from the weak environmental legacy of former Gov. Rick Scott (R), now a senator.

In an electronic mail to ThinkProgress, Yoca Arditi-Rocha, government director for the non-profit, non-partisan CLEO Institute, recommended DeSantis’ efforts and sounded a hopeful notice about bipartisanship on the local weather challenges dealing with Florida.

“We now have to shut this partisan hole and Florida can cleared the path,” she mentioned. “We now have seen an increasing number of usually, members from our congress from [both parties]… come collectively to suggest local weather motion laws that may shield all Floridians from the devastating results we’re already experiencing from our altering local weather.”

Florida is undeniably weak to world warming. The sunny state is affected by worsening warmth waves together with more and more extra lethal hurricanes, on the expense of its most weak residents, together with farmworkers and low-income communities of shade in cities like Miami.

The Everglades Basis, a non-profit devoted to defending and elevating consciousness concerning the nationwide park, additionally applauded DeSantis’ announcement.

“That is the primary governor who has demonstrated that key hyperlink between our surroundings, tourism and our tax base,” mentioned CEO Eric Eikenberg. Florida’s financial system leans closely on tourism, not least of all within the Everglades, which is among the many most endangered websites in america, threatened by sea-level rise and different byproducts of local weather change.

Do the insurance policies go far sufficient?

However some local weather advocates laced their feedback with caveats. Frank Jackalone, director of the Sierra Membership’s Florida chapter, praised the governor’s deal with nutrient air pollution (essential to tackling the algae disaster) and strikes to strengthen environmental oversight and incorporate science into state decision-making. However he additionally highlighted a number of factors of concern.

“He’s not speaking about mitigating the causes of local weather change. Throughout his marketing campaign, he wouldn’t say the phrases, he wouldn’t speak about local weather change,” Jackalone mentioned, noting that DeSantis’ new insurance policies keep away from referencing the phrases. “He’s hinted he’s not satisfied individuals are inflicting local weather change. This can be a actual drawback.”

That concern might sound acquainted to Floridians acquainted with DeSantis’ spotty environmental file. The governor notably holds a 2 p.c lifetime approval ranking from the League of Conservation Voters (LCV) for environmental votes whereas in Congress, with that quantity standing at three p.c in 2017.  Environmental teams have furthermore constantly expressed discontentment with DeSantis’ tenure as a U.S. consultant.

On the marketing campaign path in 2018, DeSantis incessantly alternated between labeling himself an environmentalist and shying away from acknowledging the existence of local weather change. That strategy has persevered regardless of latest occasions corresponding to Hurricane Michael, which made landfall with tornado-force winds final fall.

Questions on oil and gasoline

However DeSantis’ unwillingness to acknowledge local weather change isn’t the one fear for Florida’s environmentalists. The governor’s introduced plans for fracking additionally caught the attention of some skeptical advocates.

In his plans, DeSantis singled out hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, in a transfer meant to ban the follow in Florida. Fracking is infamous for its impression on the atmosphere and human well being; the oil and gasoline extraction method permits for an uptick in greenhouse gasoline emissions, thereby exacerbating world warming within the course of.

However in a press launch, the Sierra Membership expressed concern over DeSantis’ emphasis on banning “hydraulic fracturing” relatively than acid matrix limestone fracturing, which the group argues is a much more frequent follow seen in Florida. This nuance, some advocates worry, will enable for the opposite follow to proceed whereas flying below the radar. 

In the meantime, one other supply of fear is DeSantis’ caveated opposition to offshore drilling, which solely targets exercise off of Florida’s coasts. Beneath his new plan, state businesses are tasked with opposing any and all oil and gasoline actions off of each Florida coast — however environmentalists fear this isn’t clear sufficient.

“He says, ‘we’re against drilling off of Florida’s coast.’ Nicely, the place does that start? How far out from the coast would you enable drilling? One would argue that drilling wherever within the Gulf of Mexico, wherever within the Atlantic, threatens Florida’s coast,” mentioned Jackalone.

Florida voted to constitutionally ban offshore drilling final November and it’s unclear how DeSantis’ new crackdown differs from that transfer. The state solely controls its personal waters as much as three miles out, with the remaining below federal management. And whereas the Trump administration has moved to open just about all U.S. waters to offshore drilling, Florida was final yr granted a controversial exemption by former Inside Secretary Ryan Zinke.

Past environmentalists, DeSantis can also be more likely to face pushback on his plan from Florida Democrats. The state’s Senate Democratic Chief Audrey Gibson questioned in a press launch how the governor would pay for the sweeping bundle.

“Can our state funds deal with this improve? Is the plan to chop into different applications to lift the wanted funds?” she queried.

What comes subsequent?

Water points in Florida are more likely to form a lot of DeSantis’ first weeks in workplace regardless. In one other shock transfer on Thursday, DeSantis additionally reportedly requested your complete South Water Administration District board to resign; the board is notably tasked with finishing up reservoir development below the governor’s new insurance policies.

That resignation request follows ongoing stress between the governor and the board over a leasing venture to a sugar grower, highlighting an space DeSantis has vowed to crack down on. Some critics of the state’s sugar trade have alleged the sector’s runoff is related to Florida’s algae drawback.

The flurry of introduced adjustments units DeSantis up for a yr which will see local weather and environmental points dominate in a state deeply weak to local weather change. Both method, local weather advocates say they’re carefully watching to see what comes subsequent from the governor.

“DeSantis has performed extra on this entrance to deal with Florida’s water disaster throughout his first week in workplace than Gov. Scott did in eight years,” mentioned Jackalone. “However that’s not saying a lot.”


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here